Tenure Doesn't Make You a Leader

If you’ve spent two decades climbing the ladder, but you still lose your temper on a green associate, yelling at them because they don't know what you know, those years didn't buy you wisdom. They just bought you a longer resume.

Longevity doesn’t qualify you for leadership. I can name several traits, but in this case, emotional intelligence is at the top.

Here's what happened recently inside an organization. A leader, someone with nearly three decades at the company, had an outburst. Directed at a new and early-career associate. Loud enough to be heard in neighboring offices. Loud enough to reach professionals on the second floor.

And you know what happened next?

Nothing.

No one stepped in. No one said, "Hey, that's not okay." No one came to the associate's defense at the moment when it actually mattered.

Instead, they waited. Until leadership walked away. And then, only then, did someone pull the associate aside and say:

"That's just how they are. Don't take it personally."

I need you to read that again.

That's just how they are.

That’s how toxic leadership survives for decades inside organizations. Not because no one sees it. But because everyone around it has decided that longevity is an excuse. That tenure is a shield. Those 30 years of showing up somehow cancel out the damage done to the people they're supposed to be leading.

It doesn't.

Time doesn't make you a leader.

Titles don't make you a leader.

Seniority doesn't make you a leader.

What makes you a leader is how people feel when they're in the room with you. Whether they bring you their real problems or their polished ones. Whether they grow under your direction or quietly count the days until they can leave.

And here's the stat that should stop every organization in its tracks.

50 to 70% of people who leave their jobs leave because of a bad boss or a toxic manager.

Not the pay. Not the commute. Not the benefits package.

The person.

I'm not here to just call out what's broken. You know I don't do that. So let's talk about what we should be looking for, developing, and demanding in the people we put in positions of authority.

📌 1. Emotional Regulation

This is non-negotiable, and I don't care how long you've been there.

A leader who cannot manage their own emotions cannot manage people. Full stop. The ability to stay grounded when things get hard, when a new associate makes a mistake, when a deadline is missed, when something goes sideways, that is not a soft skill. That is a core leadership competency.

Your title does not give you permission to make someone feel small.

If the most powerful thing you've demonstrated in 30 years is that your outburst can be heard on the second floor, you have not been leading. You have been endured.

📌 2. Psychological Safety

Real leaders make it safe to speak up, ask questions, make mistakes, and tell the truth.

When no one in that office stepped in to defend that associate, it wasn't because they didn't know it was wrong. It was because the culture had taught them that staying quiet was safer. That is a psychological safety failure, and it starts at the top.

People do their best work when they're not afraid. They innovate when they're not walking on eggshells. They stay when they feel that someone in charge actually sees them as human beings.

Ask yourself this. Would the people on your team tell you the truth if something wasn't working? Or would they wait until you left the room?

The answer tells you everything.

📌 3. Accountability Without Ego

The best leaders I have seen in two decades of this work share one trait consistently.

They can say "I was wrong."

Not performatively. Not followed by a "but." Just a clean, honest acknowledgment that they missed the mark and here's what they're going to do differently.

Ego is the enemy of great leadership. The leader in that story likely never apologized to that associate. Likely never thought they needed to. Because in their mind, 30 years of tenure meant they had earned the right to operate however they wanted.

That's not leadership. That's entitlement wearing a lanyard.

When companies promote based on tenure instead of competency, they get exactly what they built. When they allow one person's bad behavior to be explained away with "that's just how they are," they are choosing that person over every single human being who has to work around them.

That associate who got screamed at? They filed a complaint with HR. They had several witnesses. They got moved to a different team in a separate building.

Leadership is not given.

It is earned.

Trust is built or it is broken, one interaction at a time.

That new associate deserved better. And if your organization has someone like that 30-year leader running the floor?

It's time to address that SHIfT.

Facilities Engineer

Nashville, TN | $130K-140K | Relocation: Yes

REFERENCE #MSH-601a

Why this one matters:

This is for you if you'd rather solve problems on the floor than in a slide deck.

Up to 4 more roles are waiting. Details are behind this link.